Australian spinner was once a destructive force but now concedes runs freely as South Africa set up a gripping final day at Newlands

In the penultimate over of day four of the engrossing Newlands Test, Wiaan Mulder slog-swept Nathan Lyon for six. Mulder had already reached his century. Now, Lyon reached his own century too.
When Mulder was dismissed by Pat Cummins for 115 an over later, he had set up a final day for the ages. Australia need 288 runs to win the series 2-1; South Africa need 10 wickets to clinch a come-from-behind victory. Mulder’s innings, together with the 10 wickets he has already taken this series, suggests he could join the distinguished ranks of great South African Test all-rounders.
Lyon had rather less reason to celebrate. He was recalled for the decisive Test in anticipation of conditions such as these: an essentially benign pitch, but one that offered more turn as the Test progressed. In Australia’s first innings, fellow off-spinner Simon Harmer posed a greater threat than even Kagiso Rabada and Marco Jansen, dismissing four of Australia’s top six.
With Australia first securing a 100-run lead, and then reducing South Africa to 31 for two in their second innings, Lyon was primed to win his side the series. He was introduced as early as the 12th over, a recognition of how his captain intended to use him: as simultaneously a source of economy and threat, while the quicks rotated. The enterprising Marques Ackerman apart, South Africa were too concerned about their plight to dare to attack Lyon.
When Lyon bowled Temba Bavuma on the third evening, beating the batsman’s flick with a flighted delivery, the dismissal held out the promise that the off-spinner would bowl Australia to victory the following day. Instead, Australia toiled in the field from the first ball until Mulder’s wicket finally brought about stumps.
In between times, Lyon added just a solitary wicket, clean bowling Harmer with a sharply turning off-break. Yet even this wicket was tinged with a certain frustration: Harmer has been far more threatening with the ball than Lyon in this Test.
Should the trend continue on day five, Harmer will bowl South Africa to victory. Australia have five left-handers for Harmer to attack; with his drift in the air and turn off the pitch, he can also be a menace to right-handers.
Lyon’s final figures of two for 101 from 44 overs of toil sharpened his frustrations. While Scott Boland took five for 81 in the second Test, when Lyon was absent, the off-spinner’s six wickets this series have cost 43.6 apiece. Lyon has needed 109 deliveries – 18.1 overs – to prize out each South African wicket.
These are not isolated frustrations. When Bangladesh shocked Australia in Darwin in August, Lyon took one for 125 from 36 overs in the Test.
Lyon’s regular absences from Australia’s first-choice XI have been blamed on the surfeit of grass-tinged pitches that no longer demand a specialist spinner. Yet Australia’s willingness to drop Lyon also reflects a simple truth: his bowling is no longer as effective. In his past 16 Tests, going back to the 2024‐25 home summer, Lyon has taken 47 wickets, fractionally under three per Test. The benchmark for Test bowlers is at least four wickets per match – especially when, like Lyon, their contribution is relatively meagre with the bat or in the field.
Aged 38, and after suffering a series of calf and hamstring injuries in recent years, Lyon has been weighed down by the sheer toil of his remarkable Test career. Only four men have ever bowled more than Lyon’s 35,771 deliveries in Test cricket.

How many more balls Lyon will deliver while wearing his cherished baggy green is an increasingly unavoidable question. Australia’s relentless 12 months of Test cricket – at least 20 matches in the year from this August – will deprive players of scope for recovery between games, and could thereby accelerate the end of careers. Left-arm spinner Matthew Kuhnemann, whose 25 Test wickets have come at 22.2 apiece, looms, eager to be elevated from second-choice spinner.
In Lyon’s last Ashes Test in England, he hobbled off after sustaining a calf injury, only to come out to bat while incapacitated. The moment encapsulated the spirit of Lyon: he long revelled in his role as song-master of the Australian Test team, the man responsible for beginning renditions of Under the Southern Cross I Stand. Now, the age of Lyon breaking out in song in the Australian dressing room is rapidly nearing an end.




